Can you explain the distinction between X-XSRF-TOKEN and X-CSRF-TOKEN?

Question

Can you explain the distinction between X-XSRF-TOKEN and X-CSRF-TOKEN?

What is the difference between using a hidden field and a header in web development, and why would you choose one over the other?
When do we use X-XSRF_TOKEN?
And when do we use X-CSRF TOKEN?

php security laravel-5 csrf

Answer 1

Answer №1

Each of these security measures is designed to protect against cross-site request forgery, and you only need to choose one when making a request to the backend. The names vary depending on the framework being used.

The main goal is to send a csrf value to the backend. The backend will then compare this value with the stored csrf value for that specific user in the database. If they match, the request will be processed.

csrf :

Used in HTML forms (not AJAX)
Generated by the backend when rendering the HTML form
We cannot set request headers directly in HTML forms, so it's common practice to send the csrf value via a hidden input field within the form.
You can name this hidden input field anything you like. For example:
```
<input name="my_csrf_input" value="a_hashed_string_the_csrf_value"
```

x-csrf-token:

This token is included in the request header for AJAX requests.
To use it, we can embed the csrf value in a meta tag during HTML rendering, then retrieve this value from the meta tag in the front end and include it in the request sent to the backend.
Specific to Laravel: When using Laravel as the backend, Laravel automatically checks this header and compares it to the valid csrf value stored in the database (Laravel has middleware for this purpose).

x-xsrf-token:

This token is also included in the request header for AJAX requests.
Popular libraries like Angular and Axios automatically extract the value for this header from the xsrf-token cookie and add it to every request header.
To utilize it, we need to create a cookie named xsrf-token in the backend. Front end frameworks such as Angular or Axios will then handle this automatically.
In Laravel: Due to its popularity, Laravel automatically generates this cookie in each response. Therefore, when using tools like Axios or Angular with Laravel, there is no additional setup required - simply authenticate the user and let the 'auth' middleware handle the rest.
In Laravel: The string for this token is larger compared to x-csrf-token because cookies are encrypted in Laravel.

Answer 2

Each of these security measures is designed to protect against cross-site request forgery, and you only need to choose one when making a request to the backend. The names vary depending on the framework being used.

The main goal is to send a csrf value to the backend. The backend will then compare this value with the stored csrf value for that specific user in the database. If they match, the request will be processed.

csrf :

Used in HTML forms (not AJAX)
Generated by the backend when rendering the HTML form
We cannot set request headers directly in HTML forms, so it's common practice to send the csrf value via a hidden input field within the form.
You can name this hidden input field anything you like. For example:
```
<input name="my_csrf_input" value="a_hashed_string_the_csrf_value"
```

x-csrf-token:

This token is included in the request header for AJAX requests.
To use it, we can embed the csrf value in a meta tag during HTML rendering, then retrieve this value from the meta tag in the front end and include it in the request sent to the backend.
Specific to Laravel: When using Laravel as the backend, Laravel automatically checks this header and compares it to the valid csrf value stored in the database (Laravel has middleware for this purpose).

x-xsrf-token:

This token is also included in the request header for AJAX requests.
Popular libraries like Angular and Axios automatically extract the value for this header from the xsrf-token cookie and add it to every request header.
To utilize it, we need to create a cookie named xsrf-token in the backend. Front end frameworks such as Angular or Axios will then handle this automatically.
In Laravel: Due to its popularity, Laravel automatically generates this cookie in each response. Therefore, when using tools like Axios or Angular with Laravel, there is no additional setup required - simply authenticate the user and let the 'auth' middleware handle the rest.
In Laravel: The string for this token is larger compared to x-csrf-token because cookies are encrypted in Laravel.

Answer 3

Answer №2

When sending data via AJAX, it's important to include headers for the CSRF token since AJAX does not automatically include the token with the data.

To add a hidden field for AJAX requests, you can use the following code:

$.ajaxSetup(
{
    headers:
    {
        'X-CSRF-Token': $('input[name="_token"]').val()
    }
});

However, keep in mind that you'll need to add a hidden field for every AJAX request.

The main difference between X-CSRF-TOKEN and X-XSRF-TOKEN is that the former uses a plain text value while the latter uses an encrypted value. In Laravel, cookies are always encrypted. If you're using the csrf_token() function to generate the token value, it's recommended to use the X-CSRF-TOKEN header.

While the information about this feature is no longer included in Laravel 5.2 documentation, you can still refer to the Laravel 5.0 documentation here.

Answer 4

When sending data via AJAX, it's important to include headers for the CSRF token since AJAX does not automatically include the token with the data.

To add a hidden field for AJAX requests, you can use the following code:

$.ajaxSetup(
{
    headers:
    {
        'X-CSRF-Token': $('input[name="_token"]').val()
    }
});

However, keep in mind that you'll need to add a hidden field for every AJAX request.

The main difference between X-CSRF-TOKEN and X-XSRF-TOKEN is that the former uses a plain text value while the latter uses an encrypted value. In Laravel, cookies are always encrypted. If you're using the csrf_token() function to generate the token value, it's recommended to use the X-CSRF-TOKEN header.

While the information about this feature is no longer included in Laravel 5.2 documentation, you can still refer to the Laravel 5.0 documentation here.

Answer 5

Answer №3

In addition to the excellent responses already given, it is important to mention that CSRF and XSRF are often used interchangeably.

Initially, Cross-site request forgery was known as XSRF, with the "X" standing for Cross, inspired by Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) terminology to avoid confusion with CSS.

Some frameworks have adopted "XSRF" to refer to protections using XHR, while "CSRF" is specifically for protections involving HTML forms.

Nevertheless, "CSRF" has now become the more widely accepted term in recent times.

Answer 6

In addition to the excellent responses already given, it is important to mention that CSRF and XSRF are often used interchangeably.

Initially, Cross-site request forgery was known as XSRF, with the "X" standing for Cross, inspired by Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) terminology to avoid confusion with CSS.

Some frameworks have adopted "XSRF" to refer to protections using XHR, while "CSRF" is specifically for protections involving HTML forms.

Nevertheless, "CSRF" has now become the more widely accepted term in recent times.

Can you explain the distinction between X-XSRF-TOKEN and X-CSRF-TOKEN?

Answer №1

Answer №2

Answer №3

Similar questions

Fatal PHP error: Unhandled TypeError: The first argument for count() function must be Countable or an array, an integer was provided

Issues with jquery ajax php call's functionality restrictions

What is the best way to highlight a specific city on a map by placing a circle around it?

Delay in form submission

What is the process for a server to manage numerous users concurrently?

Utilize checkbox filters to refine search results within jQuery pagination

The chosen option from the drop-down menu cannot be shown on the screen

Avoid including line breaks when using JSON_ENCODE to prevent any issues in the

Displaying every outcome of a PHP script with AJAX

Difficulty arise when AJAX array interacts with MySQL database table

Issues arising from URL encoded characters that fail to get rewritten

Retrieving Data from Database Using Laravel and Ajax Post-Update

Server response not being awaited by Ajax call

The PHP array is returned in AJAX calls, but it seems that JSON is not displaying

Leverage the power of PHP functions within your Smarty template

Retrieve the specific data from the database when the <tr> element is hovered over

Attempting to acquire the PDF file using cURL, encountering a 404 error, whereas the browser successfully retrieves it with a 206 partial

Issue with jQuery function not recognizing escaped double quotes in PHP script

troubleshooting Laravel 6 authentication issue with npm run dev command

What is the best scenario to implement ftp_pasv?