Closures are like the "use" keyword in PHP or the capture list in C++, but they play a similar role in JavaScript and other transpiler languages

PHP has a useful feature with the use keyword, which allows for the usage of 'external' variables in closures. For example:

$tax = 10;
$totalPrice = function ($quantity, $price) use ($tax){  //mandatory 'use'
    return ($price * $quantity) * ($tax + 1.0);
};

If the use ($tax) part is omitted, an error will be thrown, which I find beneficial.

In C++ 11, we can achieve a similar functionality by specifying external variables in a capture list within brackets:

float tax = 10;
auto totalPrice = [tax](int quantity, float price){   //mandatory []
   return (price*quantity) * (tax + 1.0);
};

Just like in PHP, omitting the capture list in C++ will result in an error.

However, JavaScript lacks an equivalent to the use keyword (or C++ []), so we simply do:

var tax = 10;
var totalPrice = function (quantity, price){  //no need for 'use' or similar
    return (price * quantity) * (tax + 1.0);  //tax is usable here :(
};

I find this freedom in JavaScript somewhat problematic, as I prefer explicitly stating the accessible variables in closure functions or receiving an error if not done so, for reasons beyond the scope of this question.

Therefore, I am curious to know if ES6 or any language that transpiles to JavaScript offers a special keyword or operator for this purpose (e.g., CoffeeScript, TypeScript). If such a feature exists, what is the syntax and in which language?

Ideally, I would like to be able to detect at transpiration time (or earlier) when a variable has not been explicitly 'authorized' for use in a closure, similar to PHP/C++ behavior.

Thank you in advance.

EDIT: A linter that performs this check would also be beneficial.

Answer №1

Regrettably, the keyword use does not actually exist in javascript. However, there are multiple ways to achieve the desired outcome.

Here is an example where totalPrice is a function and tax is global.

// Example provided
var tax = 10;
var totalPrice = function (quantity, price) {
    return (price * quantity) * (tax + 1.0);
};
var price = totalPrice(1, 1);
console.log ("The price is : " + price);

In my opinion, one possible solution that closely resembles the use of the keyword use is to create a function that initializes tax within a sub scope and returns a new function:

// Example 1 with returned function
function generatePriceCalculator(tax) {
    return function(quantity, price) {
        if ("undefined" === typeof tax) {
            throw "Tax is undefined";
        }

        return (price * quantity) * (tax + 1.0);
    };
};

var priceCalculator = generatePriceCalculator(20);
var price1 = priceCalculator(1, 1);
console.log ("Price for Example 1 is : " + price1);

In this scenario, the generatePriceCalculator function sets the value for tax within the returned function.

Alternatively, you can create an external function to call within the closure.

// Example 2 using a function to retrieve tax value
function getTax() {
    return 30;
}
var totalPrice2 = function (quantity, price) {
    var tax = getTax();
    return (price * quantity) * (tax + 1.0);
};
var price2 = totalPrice2(1, 1);
console.log ("Price for Example 2 is : " + price2);

You can view these examples here:

View Examples on JSFiddle

Answer №2

JavaScript does not have a specific keyword for accessing variables in different scopes.

In JavaScript, variables are accessible to all child scopes. For example:

(function() {
  var outerVariable = true;
  (function() {
    console.log(typeof outerVariable); // boolean
    (function() {
      console.log(typeof outerVariable); // boolean
    }())
  }());
}());

However, you cannot access variables that are defined in separate, non-parent scopes. For example:

(function() {
  var someVariable = true;
}());
(function() {
  console.log(typeof someVariable); // undefined
}());

It is important to write JavaScript code in a way that ensures access only to necessary variables. Consider the following example:

(function() {
  var math = (function() {
    // inner variable
    var PI = 3.141592653589793;

    // inner function
    function multiply(...args) {
      return args.reduce((a, b)=> a * b);
    }

    // outer functions
    return {
      circleArea: function circleArea(r) {
        return multiply(r, r, PI);
      },
      circumference: function circumference(r) {
        return multiply(2, PI, r);
      }
    };
  }());

  console.log(math.circleArea(5)); // 78.53981633974483
  console.log(math.circumference(10)); // 62.83185307179586

  console.log(typeof PI); // "undefined"
  console.log(typeof multiply); // "undefined"
}());

In this example, the IIFE creating the `math` object allows access to the `PI` variable and `multiply` function within its scope. The returned functions can also access `PI` and `multiply`, as they are inside the same IIFE. However, outside of this IIFE, `PI` and `multiply` are undefined.

For more information, see:

  • How do JavaScript closures work?
  • What is the purpose of wrapping whole Javascript files in anonymous functions like “(function(){ … })()”?

Answer №4

If you're searching for an alternative to the use keyword in JavaScript with the intention of improving code readability, consider using window.variablename. In JavaScript, variables declared at the global scope are automatically associated with the window object. For instance:

var window.tax = 10;
var totalPrice = function (quantity, price){
    return (price * quantity) * (window.tax + 1.0);  
};

By utilizing window.variablename, it becomes evident to anyone reviewing the code that the referenced variable is part of the global scope (specifically window.tax). This approach eliminates ambiguity and enhances code transparency.

Answer №5

Let's clear something up from the start: JavaScript is in a league of its own, distinct from PHP and C++.

use() might not be the go-to method in JS, but fear not! There are countless ways to achieve what you need in this versatile language. In addition to the solutions provided earlier, here's another example:

var tax = 'incorrect';

var priceFactory = function(tax) { 
    // private `tax` variable specific to this scope
    var tax = tax;

    // Alternatively, implement a complex check like:
    // var tax = 'number' ==  typeof tax && tax || function() { throw "No tax provided"; }();

    return function(quantity, price) {
        return (price * quantity) * (1 + tax / 100);
    }
};

var price = new priceFactory(10); // 10% tax

var totalPrice = price(1, 100)

Answer №6

It seems unlikely that JS will ever fulfill your requirements. PHP enforces strict scope rules. Any variable defined within a function is confined to that specific function. Similarly, variables defined outside of a function are not automatically accessible inside the function. The use of use or global changes where and when you can utilize a variable within a certain scope.

By default, JS places everything in the global scope. It operates in a somewhat unconventional manner, where if you want to restrict a variable's scope to a specific function, you must explicitly pass it as an argument or specifically constrain its scope.

function bob(x) {
    // x is local by default
    y = 1; //global
    var z = 2; //local
}

In essence, all variables in JS are implicitly declared using use.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

When you use array[index] in a Reduce function, the error message "Property 'value' is not defined in type 'A| B| C|D'" might be displayed

Recently, I delved deep into TypeScript and faced a challenge while utilizing Promise.allSettled. My objective is to concurrently fetch multiple weather data components (such as hourly forecast, daily forecast, air pollution, UV index, and current weather ...

Access Tokens in Azure API Application are not authorized to create contacts

Encountered an error with code NoPermissionsInAccessToken while attempting to create contacts using Application Permission in Microsoft Azure. You can view my code here: , and see what I am passing through here: http://prntscr.com/p6uiwx. ...

The pagination feature of the material-ui data grid is experiencing issues with double clicks because of its compatibility with the react-grid-layout library for

I am currently using the react-grid-layout library to manage the resizing of both charts and a material-ui data grid table. However, I am encountering an issue where when clicking on the table pagination arrow, it does not work properly. I have to click tw ...

Setting a background-image using jQuery in Codeigniter can be done by following these steps

Currently, I am developing a project in Codeigniter. In my jQuery file, I have included code to set the background image of the body element: $('body').css('background-image','url(<?php echo base_url("assets/images/bg2.png");?& ...

Rendering HTML with jQuery using AJAX: Step-by-step guide

Within my webpage, I have implemented a select box that contains a list of various books. The purpose of this select box is to allow the user to choose a book and then click a submit button in order to view the chapters of that book on a separate page. Ho ...

Utilize jQuery to swiftly align elements within a designated container

Check out my JSFiddle example: http://jsfiddle.net/c62rsff3/ I'm attempting to implement snapping behavior between 2 elements using this code: $('.draggable-elements').draggable({ snap: true }); In addition, I've defined a container ...

"Having trouble with sound in react-native-sound while playing audio on an Android AVD? Discover the solution to fix this

react-native-sound I attempted to manually configure react-native-sound but I am unable to hear any sound. The file was loaded successfully. The audio is playing, but the volume is not audible on Android AVD with react-native-sound. ...

The Google Pie chart is displaying outside of the designated div area when placed inside a dropdown menu

Encountering an issue with my pie chart rendering outside of its parent div when placed within a dropdown menu. The chart successfully loads after the page is loaded, but only displays correctly if I hover over the dropdown and allow it to load. If I do ...

Encountering an Error when Integrating Pusher (real-time data library) with Next.js: PusherRequestError - Unexpected status code 400

I encountered an issue while trying to integrate Pusher into my Next.js application due to Vercel's restriction on websockets in their serverless functions. The error message I keep receiving after running the program with Pusher is: error - unhandled ...

What separates the act of declaring a generic function from explicitly declaring a type for that very same generic function?

Here are two instances demonstrating the use of a generic function: function myGenericFunction<TFunc extends Function>(target:TFunc): string { return target.toString(); } Based on this response, this represents a declaration for a generic funct ...

On Linux systems, Node.js in JavaScript interprets strings as objects only

I'm encountering an issue with my Discord.io bot. I am attempting to run it on a Linux server, but the Linux version of Node.js keeps treating the contents of a string as a separate object, leading to the following TypeError: TypeError: Object IT&apo ...

AmCharts stacked bar chart - dynamically adjust value visibility (adjust transparency) based on user interaction

I recently utilized amcharts to construct a bar chart. The creation of my stacked bar chart was inspired by this specific example. Currently, I am attempting to modify the alpha (or color) of a box when hovering over another element on my webpage, such as ...

Using canvas to smoothly transition an object from one point to another along a curved path

As a beginner in working with canvas, I am facing a challenge of moving an object from one fixed coordinate to another using an arc. While referring to the code example of a solar system on https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Canvas_API/Tutori ...

Java - RESTful API endpoint that serves images when available and JSON data when images are not available

I am currently working on incorporating a mobile front-end using the Ionic Framework along with the $cordovaFileTransfer plugin. My focus is on fetching and uploading a person's Profile Photo. Uploading the photo is functioning properly, but I am enco ...

Utilizing jQuery to send data to a PHP script

Actually, I am not very familiar with jQuery. I have a jQuery script that passes variables to a file which displays data in JSON format. However, I am unable to show that data using the code below: $(document).ready(function() { var globalRequest = 0; ...

Upon inspecting the Logcat, a Parse error was discovered: a syntax error, specifically an unexpected ':' in the file path C:wampwwwsignup.php on line 2. This file pertains to a login

Looking for guidance in the world of PHP, I am currently tackling a basic login and registration form for testing purposes. However, as I encounter some errors, I humbly seek assistance from all of you...thank you. Below is a snippet of my code.. any help ...

Displaying entries of input data

I have an application that includes a modal window with filters, but I am looking to add another type of filter. However, I am struggling with implementing it in React and would appreciate any help with the code or recommended links. Essentially, I want t ...

Having trouble with adding a product to your cart after using the add_filter() function in woocommerce_add_to_cart_validation

In my current scenario, a non-logged-in user is restricted to adding only one product to their cart. I have implemented a filter on woocommerce_add_to_cart_validation that seems to be working correctly with $woocommerce->cart->cart_contents_count&g ...

Java REST service remains out of reach for JavaScript fetch call

Currently, I am in the process of learning about REST API. My goal is to make a call to a POST service implemented in Java from Javascript using fetch. However, I have encountered an issue where the request fails to reach the service whenever the @Produces ...

Tips for sending two values to a PHP file using JavaScript Ajax

I have created a code for two dropdown menus. The goal is to select values from both menus and send them to a php file using the GET method. The values should be sent to the php file only when both menus have selections made. Below is the code snippet: ...