Comparing MVC's return Json() Method to JSON-Based Web Services

I am eager to offer a service on my website that allows any user to request JSON data. Ultimately, I hope that users will utilize this service frequently.

My website is built using the asp.net MVC framework and I am exploring the best approach for accomplishing this...

While many would suggest using a web service (*.asmx) to return JSON, I am considering simply creating a URL that users can call to receive JSON format (e.g: visiting "" would provide a JSON list). This could be achieved in asp.net by utilizing the return Json() method.

What are the pros and cons of using this method instead of a Web Service designed specifically for this purpose?

Answer №1

When it comes to choosing between a .asmx web service or an MVC approach, opinions may vary. Personally, I haven't created a .asmx web service in a while and would prefer the MVC approach. However, there are certain considerations to keep in mind:

  1. Potential future changes to data, URLs, and/or parameters being passed in.
  2. Avoiding making the controller too large or cluttered, which could prompt the creation of a separate API controller.

In my perspective, the advantages of the MVC approach lie in its consistency with the app's overall structure, ease of use, and minimal need for configuration.

Answer №2

One of the key features of a web service is its ability to publish a WSDL.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Utilize a for loop in Vue.js to save a fresh array of objects in a structured format

Trying to achieve the following using Vue: I have two JSON objects that provide information on languages and the number of inputs per language. Using nested loops, I display all the inputs. My goal is to create an object for each input with additional det ...

Ways to conceal the jqgrid thumbnail

I have a jqgrid that displays a large amount of dynamic data. I am looking for a way to hide the thumb of the vertical scrollbar in the jqgrid when scrolling using the mousewheel. Here is a basic example: var data = [ [48803, "DSK1", "", "02200220", "O ...

What is the process for displaying node_modules directories in a json/javascript document?

Exploring ways to showcase the dependencies within my d3.js tree, I am curious if it's possible to dynamically list the dependencies' names in a JSON file or directly within the javascript file. I'm puzzled by how JavaScript can access folde ...

Every time I attempt to execute mupx deploy, an error message appears

issue in console shubhabrata@shubhabrata-VirtualBox:~/Meteor/myapp$ mupx deploy Meteor Up: Advancing Meteor Deployments for Production Configuration file : mup.json Settings file : settings.json “ Discover Kadira! A powerful tool to monitor yo ...

struggling with responseText functionality in javascript

I am encountering an issue with passing variables from PHP to JavaScript using JSON. The problem lies in the fact that I am able to debug and view the items in the responseText within my JavaScript, but I am unable to assign them to a variable or properly ...

Encountering an issue with Vue JS axios request and filter: the function this.XX.filter is not operational

I am encountering challenges while trying to implement a basic search feature on a JSON file obtained through an API. Each component works independently: I can successfully retrieve data from the API, perform searches on non-API data, and even search cert ...

Ways to rearrange an object with javascript

I am looking to restructure my object by removing a nesting. How can I achieve this using JavaScript? Actual: var a = [ { clickedEvents: { 'event-element': 'a', 'event-description': & ...

Blogger's homepage URL obtained using JSON data

Please note: I don't have a background in programming. I'm making an effort to learn as much as possible. As I was reading (and later experimenting with) the solution to this query, it dawned on me that having the same information in JSON form ...

Transforming a single object into multiple arrays using AngularJS

Just starting out with AngularJS and I've got some data that looks like this { day1: 0, day2: 0, day3: 0, day4: 2 } Is there a way to convert this data into arrays structured like below? [     ["day1": 0],     ["day2": 0],   ...

Ways to verify if JSON.parse fails or yields a falsy outcome

Objective: const jsonData = JSON.parse(this.description) ? JSON.parse(this.description) : null When executing the above statement, my aim is to have the ability to parse a value successfully and return null if parsing fails. However, instead of achieving ...

Extracting Data from JSON Structures

I am struggling with extracting data from a JSON string that looks like this: var txt= '{“group”: [ {“family1”: { “firstname”:”child1”, “secondname”:”chlid2” }}, {“family2”: { ...

Mapping JSON schema to typed JavaScript objects

Are there any tools available to generate JavaScript typed objects (JS functions) from a JSON schema? Essentially, looking for the JS equivalent of this http://code.google.com/p/jsonschema2pojo/. Thank you. EDIT: Starting with: { "description": "An ...

Making a XMLHttpRequest/ajax request to set the Content-Type header

In my attempts, I have tested the following methods individually: Please note: The variable "url" contains an HTTPS URL and "jsonString" contains a valid JSON string. var request = new XMLHttpRequest(); try{ request.open("POST", url); request.set ...

Processing a JSON array of objects in AngularJS

When using Angular's fromJson function to parse a JSON string, I encountered an issue. If the JSON is a simple array like "[1, 2]", the code works fine. However, I need to work with an array of dictionaries instead. var str = "[{'title' ...

Locate a specific data point within an array of JSON objects

After receiving an array of JSON objects from JSP, I now have a set of data that contains book titles. "Titles":[ { "Book3" : "BULLETIN 3" } , { "Book1" : "BULLETIN 1" } , { "Book2" : "B ...

When using JSON.stringify on a map object, it returns an empty result

var map1= new Map(); map1.set("one",1); var map2 = new Map(); map2.set("two",2); concatMap = {}; concatMap['one']= map1; concatMap['two']= map2; JSON.stringify(concatMap); //outputs : "{"one":{},"two":{}}" I als ...

Tips for accurately determining the count, rather than the character length, of JSON data

After running my code, I believe it returns a JSON array. The resulting JSON array is then stored in a JavaScript variable called 'result'. When I console.log(result); in Firefox, the output shown is: [{"id":"G24","value":"Zas, S"},{"id":"G75" ...

Strip away double quotation marks from object attributes except those beginning with a number

I've searched extensively and reviewed various Q&A forums, but I haven't encountered a scenario quite like this. Here's an example of the object I'm working with: props: { "label": "1rem", "text3": "1rem", "text2Button": "1re ...

The command "npm run build:css " is not functioning properly, but when I execute the script independently, it works fine

Recently, while working on a program using npm script on my Mac system, I encountered some issues. Despite having installed node-sass globally, running "npm run build:css" did not work as expected. The content of my package.json file can be viewed here. Th ...

Show the current temperature data retrieved from the weather API

I'm trying to figure out what's causing the issue with the temperature not displaying. Can anyone help me identify and fix the error? <script type="text/javascript"> $.ajax({ url: 'https://api.weather.gov/gridpoints/EWX ...