Could my HTML security measures be vulnerable to exploitation?

I have successfully developed a function that accomplishes the following:

  1. It accepts a string as input, which can be either an entire HTML document or an HTML "snippet" (even if it's broken).
  2. It creates a DOMDocument from the input and iterates through all nodes.
  3. Whenever it comes across a node with an element outside of a whitelist of basic structural elements, it marks it for deletion. For instance, <script> is not whitelisted.
  4. If a node has any attribute starting with "on," it is promptly removed using removeAttribute. The same applies to any "style" attribute, and any "href" attribute whose value begins with "javascript:".
  5. Once all nodes have been processed, the marked nodes are deleted (
    $node->parentNode->removeChild($node)
    ). This step is deferred because deleting them in the first loop can cause confusion for the parser.
  6. The resulting document is then saved using saveHTML and returned as a cleaned/secured HTML document/snippet represented as a string.

Based on my assessment, there seems to be no exploitable vulnerabilities in this process. Unless there is a flaw in the DOM parser, which is beyond my control/concern.

However, could there be another "onsomething" attribute or some other potential vulnerability that I am overlooking?

I am quite confident in the output of cleaning any HTML sourced from an untrusted external/user-provided origin after being processed by this function. But perhaps I am overconfident?

(I really wish that strip_tags could handle this automatically so I wouldn't have had to develop my own solution.)

Answer №1

To mitigate the risk of xss attacks, it is advisable to remove all on* attributes from your code. Additionally, be cautious of using style and href (specifically javascript:) as they could potentially contain malicious scripts in certain browsers. SVG files also have the capability to include scripts that may pose a security threat.

For more information on how xss sanitizers can be bypassed, refer to this resource. It highlights the challenges of developing effective sanitization methods and emphasizes the importance of using established solutions like Google Caja.

Instead of creating your own sanitizer, consider utilizing reputable tools like Google Caja for better protection against xss vulnerabilities. Building a reliable sanitizer is a complex task that requires extensive expertise.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Updating multiple rows in Laravel using input data

Check out the app here I recently created a multi-row update feature with JavaScript. The button function successfully retrieves the ID of each row, but now I'm facing a challenge. I want to include an input form for the data that is being updated. ...

Discover the Ultimate Guide on Altering the Course of Mega Menu!

I am working on a mega menu that is set to display in the usual direction. However, for the last two items, I would like them to appear from the button upwards. I'm not quite sure how to explain it. What I envision is something similar to this: ...

My JavaScript code is being executed before Chrome Auto-fill

I have successfully created form input elements in Chrome that display a floating label when focused. However, I am encountering an issue when the browser autofills the username and password fields with yellow prefilled text. The JavaScript for the float ...

What is the most effective method for displaying two external web pages next to each other?

Looking for a solution to display an English Wikipedia article on the left side of the page alongside its Spanish version on the right side. Wondering if it's possible using HTML, JavaScript, AJAX, etc. I am aware that I could use iframes, but I woul ...

Using the Kohana cache module to optimize performance on dynamically generated pages

I am currently developing a website that has a user-specific homepage. I have a question regarding Kohana's caching system - will it regenerate the cache every time a different user accesses the homepage? The link to the homepage will remain constant ...

Delivering HTML with Python Socket Server

I am currently learning about HTTP/CGI and exploring how to display HTML content on a webpage through the use of the socket library in Python. However, I am encountering some confusion regarding the correct syntax for this task: #!/usr/bin/env python impo ...

Troubleshooting a JQuery AJAX Autocomplete problem involving PHP and MySQL

I am facing an issue with my autocomplete feature. It is functioning properly on one of my pages, but not on this particular page. Even though the correct number of entries is being retrieved, they all appear to be "blank" or are displayed in black text th ...

A guide on incorporating text into a file utilizing JSP within HTML

I am working on a project that includes a JSP file and a .txt file. The JSP file contains a text field and a button, where the user can enter a text and click the button to store it in the .txt file. I have provided my code below, but I seem to be missin ...

Utilizing PHP and Ajax to showcase individual row details within a while loop upon clicking a hyperlink

In the midst of a new project, I find myself faced with a task where the user can log in and view their personal delivery orders. The list of deliveries is generated using a while loop. However, whenever I click on the details button for an item in the lis ...

Steps to supplying the private key when using the openssl_private_decrypt() function

I have encrypted a value using my public key but I am unable to decrypt it with my private key. Is there something wrong with my code? Here is the script that I am using: <?php $encrypted = "Q4tmeBDTS+M2UriF6zNBJYrWcXJuyclWVAFLZaOSNwTS0FOkqd/7yQ9KrwL ...

Having issues with the functionality of the Previous/Next button in my table

I am facing a challenge with my table as I am trying to include previous/next button for users to navigate through it. However, the interaction doesn't seem to be functioning properly, and I suspect that I need to establish a connection between the bu ...

Can you identify the attribute used for marking up an HTML code tag?

While examining a website's code to understand how they styled a specific section of their page, I came across the following snippet: <code markup="tt"> I thoroughly checked for any other references to this particular markup attribute ...

Encountering a problem with the divLogoBlock element in the code snippet below

I am experiencing an issue with the code below. The divLogoBlock does not appear when I copy and paste the entire page into Outlook as a signature. I believe there may be a problem with the CSS. Can someone please assist me? <html lang="en"><he ...

Is it possible to produce data on the server and then transmit it to the client?

Can you provide guidance on creating a webpage that prompts a python script to run on the server, and then displays the output of the script back in the browser? I'm put time into researching and seeking assistance during my web programming course. A ...

Tips for choosing the parent's parent and applying a width of 100%

I am currently facing some challenges while creating a simple navigation bar from scratch. I am struggling with setting specific widths, especially wanting .navbarDropBtn to align its width with .navbarMain. However, it seems to only match the width of the ...

Drupal encountering memory issues due to PHP/MySQL integration

Working within a local Drupal CMS environment has been smooth sailing so far, with easy navigation and page access for viewing or editing. However, an issue arises when attempting to save changes or delete pages, leading to one of two errors popping up. E ...

The specified function is not recognized within the HTMLButtonElement's onclick event in Angular 4

Recently diving into Angular and facing a perplexing issue: "openClose is not defined at HTMLButtonElement.onclick (index:13)" Even after scouring through various resources, the error seems to be rooted in the index page rather than within any of the app ...

Modify the color of a div element in React when it is clicked on

My goal is to change the color of each div individually when clicked. However, I am facing an issue where all divs change color at once when only one is clicked. I need help in modifying my code to achieve the desired behavior. Below is the current implem ...

Writing CSS rules for generating HTML code when sending emails through the command line in Go

When trying to compose HTML with CSS for email delivery using Go command line execution, errors related to CSS properties are popping up. For instance, it's showing "not found" error in the terminal for properties like background: rgb(255, 255, 255) o ...

VUE 3 inexplicably failing to display the custom component's template, console remains error-free

I am utilizing flask, html, js for building a web application. I am currently facing an issue where the template defined in the component <add-movie> within movies.js is not being rendered into add_movies.html. The add_movies.html extends base_admin ...