Could Warmup Requests in NodeJS Lead to Data Corruption?

I currently have a running node server in App Engine standard with a custom domain and everything is functioning smoothly.

However, whenever I deploy a new version, there is a noticeable increase in latency as the old instances are halted and new ones are started.

According to the documentation, it seems that I need to take the following steps:

  1. To enable warmup requests, I should add the following code snippet to my app.yaml file: 
    inbound_services:
      - warmup
  2. Create a handler specifically dedicated to '/_ah/warmup' endpoint.
  3. Deploy the new version without promoting using the command 'gcloud deploy --no-promote app.yaml'.
  4. From the App Engine versions page, use the Migrate feature to transfer traffic from the previous version to the new one.

As someone who is relatively new to App Engine, I find the documentation to be rather ambiguous and this has raised a few questions and concerns:

  1. What exactly is the purpose of the '/_ah/warmup' handler? Since I initialize all necessary components when the node app starts, it seems redundant for this handler to do anything.
  2. Is the creation of the '/_ah/warmup' handler optional? Based on my understanding, it should be since I recall reading that a 404 response would suffice.
  3. If the creation of the handler is not optional, what type of response is expected?
  4. This question is particularly pressing!

In my attempts to solve this issue (omitting the handler), I noticed that the "Migrate" button becomes available and appears to successfully transfer traffic to the new version. However, after some time, my website starts experiencing failures. Curiously, the type of failure varies with each migration - one instance involved corrupted/invalid HTML, another had a JavaScript syntax error, and yet another resulted in the entire site being wrapped within an unattributed PRE tag! The only way I have managed to "resolve" these corruptions is by removing 'inbound_services: - warmup' from app.yaml file and redeploying.

Adding further strangeness to the situation, these corruptions exclusively occur when accessing the site through the custom domain. If I access it via the appspot.com address, everything works perfectly fine.

This same code has been operational for more than a year on a conventional web server without any issues.

To put it simply, this problem is really perplexing me. Any assistance or insights would be greatly appreciated.

node.jsgoogle-app-engine

Answer №1

In most cases, warmup requests are not necessary for deploying new versions (unless the current traffic volume is too high for a single instance to handle). Warmup requests come into play when you already have at least one running instance and need additional instances to handle incoming traffic increases. It's essential that these new instances are started with the same version as the running ones. The new instances won't receive any live traffic until they successfully complete the warmup requests, indicating their readiness to handle real user requests.

Although warmup requests are optional, skipping them can result in increased latency during dynamic scaling when additional instances are launched to cope with traffic surges. However, if you choose not to use warmup requests, ensure that the warmup inbound service is not enabled either. In other words, steps 1 and 2 on your list go hand in hand—you should either perform both or none of them.

If you only execute step 1 without step 2, there might be occasional outages during deployments. GAE may initiate multiple instance starts during traffic migration and send warmup requests to some instances. Since these instances lack a warmup handler, the requests would fail, causing GAE to consider them unhealthy and attempt to restart. To verify this theory, you can monitor the "Instances" screen on the developer console, select the newly deployed service version, and check the "Created" and "Active" figures in the "Instances" graph. However, even if confirmed, it remains uncertain whether such events could explain the symptoms you described.

On your list, only steps 3 and 4 are relevant for minimizing latency during the deployment of new versions. When employed correctly, these steps should prevent any loss of traffic, assuming the new version is free of faults. At least, that's the theory.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Ways to configure an Express.js server file with the router path set as the root directory

I have a directory structure set up like this root private js css index.html app.js privateRouter.js ... Within my index.html, I am referencing the js and css files using relative paths: <link rel="stylesheet" href="css/index.css" ...

htmlnode.jsexpress

Using `Grunt --force` results in a node error: incorrect option chosen

I am encountering an issue with my Grunt task named eslint:jenkins which is responsible for running eslint on the project. In the build pipeline, I execute it using the following command: grunt eslint:jenkins --force --verbose To prevent the grunt from f ...

node.jsgruntjs

Troubleshooting issue: res.render not functioning properly when used with Angular routing

I have developed a web application using node.js, express, angular (with routes), and mongo. The authentication process is handled by Passport.js. In my angular views, I make HTTP requests to interact with the server. For example, if I send a request of t ...

node.jsauthenticationexpressangular-routing

Can one initiate a server within Zapier Code?

Is there a way to send an HTTP CODE = 200 with a response body of 'OK' when receiving a notification on Zapier? I attempted to use the following code snippet in Zapier: var http = require('http'); const server = http.createServer((r ...

javascriptnode.jszapier

Error message stating: "A missing module (MODULE_NOT_FOUND) was detected in the nest.js code

Having a code base that runs smoothly on a Windows machine using node v10.16.3, I encountered an issue when trying to install the same code on a CentOS Linux box with node v12.16.3. The error message displayed is regarding a missing module '@angular-d ...

node.jsangularnpmnestjs

Encountering difficulties when attempting to upload a file to Google Cloud Platform using Multer in a Node.js

I am currently experimenting with uploading a single file using Multer and the "multipart/form-data" content type to a Google Cloud Storage bucket. For this task, I am utilizing "Multer.memoryStorage()" and "@google-cloud/storage" try { const docume ...

node.jstypescriptgoogle-cloud-storagebuffermulter

Tips for patiently waiting for a function that is filled with promises

Consider the following function: const getData = () => { foo() .then(result => { return result; }) .catch(error => { return error; }); }; Even though getData does not directly return a promise, it internally handles asynchro ...

javascriptnode.jspromise

What yields greater performance in MongoDB: employing multiple indexes or creating multiple collections?

Currently, I am developing an application that validates users through various 3rd party services such as Facebook and Google. Each user is assigned a unique internal id (uuid v4) which corresponds to their 3rd party ids. The mongoose schema for my user do ...

javascriptnode.jsmongodbmongoose

Sending an incomplete body in POST requests to a NodeJS API using Postman may lead to unexpected results, however, this issue may not occur

I am experiencing an issue with receiving empty bodies in POST requests through Postman in a NodeJS API. When I send the request as "form" or as "raw" with "text", I receive exactly this: {}, but if I send it as a "JSON" in raw, it simply freezes at "loadi ...

node.jsapiexpresspostbody-parser

Is there a way to prevent the jsonPayload in stackdriver from automatically converting to a struct format?

When working with a Google Cloud Function, I am logging a simple JSON structure like this: console.info(JSON.stringify({message: 'xxx', data: {status: 200}, status: 200})); However, the log appears in an unreadable format in Stackdriver. How ca ...

javascriptnode.jsgoogle-cloud-functionsserverlessgoogle-cloud-stackdriver

POST method is not permitted on Expressjs 405

While the route functions perfectly in POSTMAN's chrome extension, it doesn't seem to work with Angular. Here is my Express js code : var express = require('express'); var router = express.Router(); var app = express(); var bodyParse ...

angularjsnode.jsexpress

Is it permissible to make alterations to npm modules for node.js and then share them publicly?

I have made modifications to a module called scribe.js that I use in my own module, which is published on npm. Instead of using the original module as a dependency for my module, I would like to include my modified version. I am unsure about the legal impl ...

javascriptnode.jsnpm

When there are numerous websocket connections in Google Chrome, Socket.io can encounter issues and break down

I am encountering an issue where I create 60 client connections to a socket.io server using Google Chrome browser. The server sends screenshots to the clients at specific times, but some of the websocket connections, which are subprotocols of socket.io, ge ...

javascriptnode.jsgoogle-chromewebsocketsocket.io

What is the best way to access attributes from a div element?

I am currently working on extracting attributes from within a div tag, specifically the custom attributes of the first child element. I am using web scraping techniques with Node.js and Puppeteer. My goal is to retrieve the custom attributes data-ticker, d ...

javascripthtmljquerycssnode.js

What is the best way to link CSS files from libraries that are downloaded using npm?

For instance, let's say I installed a package: npm install --save package and it gets saved in ./node_modules/package/ Inside that folder, there might be a directory named styles and within that directory, you could find style.css. How can I link ...

javascripthtmlcssnode.jsnpm

Looking for a way to verify if a given date falls within a range of two other dates in Node.js using Sequelize?

One of the tasks involves checking if the date entered by the user falls within the range specified in the start_Date and end_Date columns in a MySQL database. This needs to be implemented using NodeJS. ...

mysqlnode.jssequelize.js

What is preventing me from importing files from a directory labeled 'individuals'?

Currently, I am working on a MEAN app and encountered some issues with my Angular folder structure. Here are the errors I am facing: https://i.stack.imgur.com/UAliy.png Interestingly, when I changed the name of the 'users' folder to something el ...

angularjsnode.jshttpdirectorynaming

Dynamic inheritance in Node.js based on the version being used

Why does the code provided only function correctly in Node.js versions 5.x and 6.x, but not in versions 4.x and older? Is there a way to modify the code so that it can work across Node.js versions 0.10.x - 6.x? 'use strict'; var util = require ...

javascriptnode.js

When using Multer for file upload, the req.body returns as an empty object while req.file is undefined

I previously shared a problem I encountered while using multer for file upload in the MERN stack. Despite my attempts, I have not yet been able to resolve it. In my app, I am using both body-parser and multer. Here is the order of code in my index.js file: ...

javascriptnode.jsexpressmultipartform-datamulter

Is it possible to simultaneously wait for the completion of two methods instead of awaiting each one individually?

When dealing with 2 async methods, one may want to run them simultaneously but wait for both to finish before proceeding. Here is an example: exports.get = async id => { const part1 = await context.get(id); const part2 = await context.get2(id ...

javascriptnode.js