Maximizing Python efficiency - the ultimate strategy for parallel computing

I am currently developing a Python script that requires sending over 1500 packets simultaneously within less than 5 seconds each.

In essence, the main requirements are:

def send_packets(ip):
    #craft packet
    while True:
        #send packet
        time.sleep(randint(0,3))

for x in list[:1500]:
    send_packets(x)
    time.sleep(randint(1,5))

I have experimented with various methods including single-threaded, multithreading, multiprocessing, and multiprocessing combined with multithreading. However, I encountered the following challenges:

  1. Single-threaded Approach: The delay introduced by the "for" loop compromised the 5 second time constraint.
  2. Multithreading: Issues arose primarily due to Python Global Interpreter Lock (GIL) restrictions.
  3. Multiprocessing: While this was initially effective, running 1500 processes caused my VM to freeze, making it impractical.
  4. Multiprocessing + Multithreading: Despite reducing the number of processes, I still faced limitations in achieving high concurrency, possibly due to GIL or VM constraints. I also tested using Process Pool without significant improvement.

Is there a more efficient approach that I could explore to achieve this task?

[1] EDIT 1:

 def send_pkt(x):
     #crafting packet
     while True:
         #sending packet
         gevent.sleep(0)

 gevent.joinall([gevent.spawn(send_pkt, x) for x in list[:1500]])

[2] EDIT 2 (gevent monkey-patching):

from gevent import monkey; monkey.patch_all()

jobs = [gevent.spawn(send_pkt, x) for x in list[:1500]]
gevent.wait(jobs)
#for send_pkt(x) check [1]

However, an error occurred: "ValueError: filedescriptor out of range in select()". Upon investigation, I found that my system's ulimit values were at their maximum. It appears that the issue lies with Linux's limitations on the usage of select(), suggesting the use of poll() as an alternative. However, poll() reintroduces similar constraints due to its blocking nature.

Best Regards,

Answer №1

One effective way to implement parallelism in Python is by utilizing either ThreadPoolExecutor or ProcessPoolExecutor found on the official Python documentation. I have personally found these methods to work efficiently.

Here is a sample code using ThreadPoolExecutor that can be tailored to suit your requirements:

import concurrent.futures
import urllib.request
import time

IPs = ['168.212. 226.204',
        '168.212. 226.204',
        '168.212. 226.204',
        '168.212. 226.204',
        '168.212. 226.204']

def send_pkt(x):
    status = 'Failed'
    while True:
        #send pkt
        time.sleep(10)
        status = 'Successful'
        break
    return status

with concurrent.futures.ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=5) as executor:
    future_to_ip = {executor.submit(send_pkt, ip): ip for ip in IPs}
    for future in concurrent.futures.as_completed(future_to_ip):
        ip = future_to_ip[future]
        try:
            data = future.result()
        except Exception as exc:
            print('%r generated an exception: %s' % (ip, exc))
        else:
            print('%r sent %s' % (url, data))

Answer №2

Upon further examination, the issue of the VM freezing due to an excessive quantity of processes running while executing a script raises questions. It is unclear whether this issue stems from shortcomings in the multiprocessing approach or limitations of the VM itself based on current information.

A potential solution could involve conducting a scaling experiment by varying the number of processes involved in sending data. Testing different configurations, such as distributing the workload among varying numbers of processes, may provide insights into performance optimization.

To analyze any potential bottlenecks resulting from different parallelism choices, tools like xperf for Windows or oprofile for Linux can be utilized. By monitoring factors like CPU cache usage and memory allocation, it becomes possible to identify optimal settings for improved performance.

In line with previous experiences, it is generally recommended to match the number of multiprocessing processes with available CPU cores for optimal efficiency. However, exceptions may exist if certain operations benefit from a higher number of processes for better resource utilization. Profiling and additional scaling experiments are necessary to determine the most effective approach.

Answer №3

While Python is typically single-threaded, it's important to note that handling tasks such as sending network packets falls under IO-bound operations, making it a suitable candidate for multi-threading. Your main thread can remain unoccupied while the packets are being transmitted, especially if you write your code with an asynchronous approach in mind.

For more information on implementing async TCP networking in Python, check out the official documentation at https://docs.python.org/3/library/asyncio-protocol.html#tcp-echo-client.

Answer №4

When dealing with a bottleneck that is http based (referred to as "sending packets"), the Global Interpreter Lock (GIL) should not pose a major problem.

However, if there are computations taking place within Python, then the GIL could potentially obstruct progress. In such cases, process-based parallelism would be the recommended approach.

A common misconception is thinking that each task requires its own process. Fortunately, utilizing Python's Pool class allows for the creation of a group of workers that can receive tasks from a queue efficiently.


import multiprocessing


def send_pkts(ip):
   ...


number_of_workers = 8

with multiprocessing.Pool(number_of_workers) as pool:
    pool.map(send_pkts, list[:1500])

By implementing this setup, you will have a total of number_of_workers + 1 processes running simultaneously (the workers along with the original process), all executing the send_pkts function concurrently.

Answer №5

Your quest for optimal performance is hindered by a specific bottleneck: the send_pkts() method. This method not only sends packets but also crafts them:

def send_pkts(ip):
#craft packet
while True:
    #send packet
    time.sleep(randint(0,3))

Sending packets is mainly an I/O bound task, while crafting packets leans towards being a CPU bound task. To address this issue effectively, it's essential to separate these tasks into two distinct processes:

  1. Crafting a packet
  2. Sending a packet

To assist in resolving this issue, I've developed a basic socket server and client application that work together to craft and transmit packets efficiently. The concept involves segregating the packet crafting process into a standalone entity that generates packets placed in a shared queue. Concurrently, a pool of threads pulls these packets from the queue and dispatches them to the server. Furthermore, the responding data from the server is stored in another common queue, primarily utilized for testing purposes rather than core functionality. These threads terminate when they encounter a None signal (commonly referred to as a poison pill) within the queue.

The `server.py` script showcases the setup for the socket server, while `client.py` demonstrates the configuration for clients sending packets:

`server.py`:

[python code here]

`client.py`:

[python code here]

A bash script `run.sh` automates the execution of the server and client scripts with varying parameters to assess performance under different conditions:

[bash script here]

$ ./run.sh -s=1024 -n=1500 -t=300 -h=localhost -p=9999

1500 packets received in 4.70330023765564 seconds

$ ./run.sh -s=1024 -n=1500 -t=1500 -h=localhost -p=9999

1500 packets received in 1.5025699138641357 seconds

For accurate insights, consider setting the log level in `client.py` to `DEBUG`. Please note the script duration may exceed the time reported due to finalization overhead when using multiple threads. Despite this, thread processing concludes around the 4.7-second mark according to logs.

It’s vital to interpret performance outcomes cautiously based on system specifications. For reference, my system comprises:

- 2 Xeon X5550 @2.67GHz - 24MB DDR3 @1333MHz - Debian 10 - Python 3.7.3

An overview of encountered issues during optimization attempts:

  1. Single-threaded approach: Expected minimum completion time of 1.5 x num_packets due to delay
  2. Multithreading challenges: Probable GIL bottleneck, particularly influenced by packet crafting operations
  3. Multiprocessing limitations: Potential constraints on file descriptors due to set limits; adjustments might be necessary
  4. Mixed multiprocessing and multithreading concerns: Likely failure due to intensive CPU bound nature of packet crafting

Remember, adhere to the rule of thumb—Threads for I/O bound tasks, Processes for CPU-bound operations.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Does modifying a variable during a recursive call count as mutation?

I want to calculate the sum of a list without using mutation. def noMutSum(lst, pointer=0, result=0): if pointer == len(lst): return result newResult = result + lst[pointer] return noMutSum(lst, pointer+1, newResult) Is changing the ...

argparse default values for multiple arguments

My goal is to utilize argparse in order to define an option that accepts three integer values, such as specifying a range with a start, end, and step. parser.add_argument('--range', nargs=3, metavar=('start', 'end', 'st ...

Encountering a problem while executing a Python script with Selenium on GCP Cloud Run

I have a Python script that requires logging in and retrieving an access_token from an authentication server. The process involves navigating to the authentication server's URL, entering a username and password, clicking 'login', waiting for ...

Organize logging messages on a per-second basis for better readability

Developed a logger responsible for logging certain canbus values to a file in seconds-based timestamps. A sample of the log is as follows: Timestamp, Can ID, data, datalength 07-Nov-22 13:40:41, 418385469, a00f325bffffffff, 8 07-Nov-22 13:40:41, 217056317, ...

"Troubleshooting: HtmlResponse functioning correctly in Scrapy Shell, yet encountering issues in script

While working on a scraping project, I decided to use scraperAPI.com for IP rotation. In my attempt to incorporate their new post request method, I encountered an error stating 'HtmlResponse' object has no attribute 'dont_filter'. Below ...

Create a Python function that takes a list as input, iterates through each element, converts it to

When working with a Python list that requires double quotes around the strings in order to pass it to an API as a list of double quote strings, I encountered an issue. The data needed by the API: data = { "styles" : styleList } It worked when I manu ...

Python's ability to communicate serially through a USB port may cease to function after several reconnects

I have a Python script that establishes serial communication with an Arduino board via the serial port. The Python library "pyserial" is used in this code, which I am running on Python 2.7. To create the connection, the following line of code is used: ...

Tips for ensuring a page has fully loaded before extracting data using requests.get in Python without relying on an API

Currently, I am using Python along with the requests library for web-scraping. I've encountered an issue regarding the loading of a page; I would like to implement a delay before receiving the result from requests.get(). I have come across some indiv ...

Issues with the proper display of Bootstrap 4 in Django are causing problems

I am currently in the process of setting up Django to work with Bootstrap. Despite my efforts, I can't seem to get it functioning correctly and I'm unsure of where I may be making a mistake. Initially, I am just trying to display a panel. You can ...

Tips for waiting for a button to be clicked by the user in Selenium web-driver with Python?

I have a Login form with a username, password, captcha text field, and SIGN-IN button. The elements are clickable and visible from the beginning. https://i.stack.imgur.com/rHbms.png With Selenium, I am able to provide input for the username and password ...

Is it possible for the python responder library to function within a conda environment?

I'm attempting to utilize the responder package (https://github.com/taoufik07/responder) within a conda environment. However, I am encountering the following issue: conda create --name tmp python=3.7 conda activate tmp conda install -c conda-forge res ...

Python Selenium WebDriver ImportError even when updated to latest version

I am encountering an issue while attempting to utilize Selenium in Python 2.7. When trying to import 'webdriver', I am getting the error message "ImportError: cannot import name webdriver". I have searched for solutions and it appears that updati ...

Having trouble executing orders with Python through the Binance API

Whenever I attempt to place an order, I encounter the following error: binance.exceptions.BinanceAPIException: APIError(code=-1111): Precision is over the maximum defined for this asset. This is my code snippet: pos = "SELL" ...

What is the most effective way to iterate over a list of strings and utilize them in a condition statement?

source = open("file1") out = open("file2", "w") months = ['Jan', 'Feb', 'Mar', 'Apr', 'May', 'Jun', 'Jul'] for line in source: out.write(line) if line.startswith('REPL ...

Using Boolean and Logical Operators in Python

When presented with two boolean input values, the following results should be printed: True True -> False True False -> False False True -> False False False -> True An attempt was made using the code below: if boolInput1 and boolInput2 == ...

Converting JSON data to a pandas DataFrame requires the list indices to be integers

I have a large JSON dataset that I want to convert to CSV for analysis purposes. However, when using json_normalize to build the table, I encounter the following error: Traceback (most recent call last): File "/Users/Home/Downloads/JSONtoCSV/easybill.py" ...

Connecting JSON objects based on unique GUID values generated

I am in search of a method to automate the laborious task of linking multiple JSON objects with random GUIDs. The JSON files are all interconnected: { "name": "some.interesting.name", "description": "helpful desc ...

Accessing and manipulating web elements using either XPath or CSS selectors

Having trouble selecting a specific piece of information using xpath or css selector. Error messages keep appearing. Can someone help identify the issue? This snippet is from my code: output = driver.find_element_by_xpath("//td[@class_= 'sku']" ...

What is preventing me from importing selenium?

Why am I unable to import selenium? Here is how my code appears in Visual Studio Code: https://i.stack.imgur.com/Goqde.png This issue only started after I upgraded to Windows 11, which resulted in the deletion of the C-drive. Does anyone have a solution ...

What are the steps for obtaining the Gaussian filter?

I need to create a Gaussian window with dimensions of m rows and n columns. I have successfully achieved this in one dimension as shown below. from scipy.stats import multivariate_normal multivariate_normal(mean=[1, 5], cov=(2.5)) Now I am looking to ex ...