What is the reason behind npm's decision to categorize dependencies into two separate categories?

Within your package.json, you will find the sections for dependencies and devDependencies.

{
  "devDependencies": {
    "webpack": "^4.42.1"
  },
  "dependencies": {
    "react": "^16.13.1"
  }
}

The purpose behind this division is clear:

  • dependencies are necessary for the application to function
  • devDependencies are only required during development

But why separate them? What advantages does it offer?

What if you include all dependencies under dependencies like this?

{
  "dependencies": {
    "react": "^16.13.1",
    "webpack": "^4.42.1"
  }
}

Will there be any performance implications? Is splitting dependencies primarily important when planning to publish a module?


This question isn't about: What's the difference between dependencies, devDependencies and peerDependencies in npm package.json file?

That particular question delves into defining what dependencies and devDependencies entail, which has already been clarified earlier.

This inquiry focuses on the reason behind segregating dependencies in this manner. Some individuals build their applications directly on the production server, while others, like myself, prefer offline builds before deploying just the index.html and main.js artifacts. As such, certain considerations may not apply in my case.

Furthermore, upon further examination, it appears that devDependencies may not contribute to the size of the main.js bundle as expected, at least within my project setup. I noticed no discernible size discrepancy whether I split the dependencies or kept them all under dependencies. Since I solely ship the final build artifact, this distinction doesn't impact my production workflow.

Answer №1

It's extremely beneficial to have two separate categories for dependencies: development-time and runtime. This division ensures that when you publish your code, unnecessary items like development tools such as jest, linting tools, or prettier are not included in the package received by others who install it. Including these development-specific packages would only bloat the size of your package unnecessarily.

This becomes especially crucial if you plan on sharing your code for others to easily install using 'npm'. Users installing your package do not require all the development-oriented modules; they only need what is necessary for running the actual code.

'npm', the Node Package Manager, plays a key role in managing node modules by distinguishing between those needed for building the code and those required at runtime. When cloning a project from its git repository and running an 'npm install', all dependency modules are loaded into the 'node_modules/' directory. However, during actual usage of the module, only the 'dependencies' are essential while the 'devDependencies' can be omitted. For 'npm', understanding this difference is crucial for effectively packaging the module.

When distributing your module on 'npm' (or a local npm repository) and other developers begin utilizing it, it's important to provide them with a streamlined version that excludes development-specific components. This minimalistic approach allows the module to function efficiently without unnecessary clutter.

In contrast to some other languages where a makefile may handle the build process and exclude certain folders, in JavaScript projects managed by 'npm', the 'package.json' file serves as the equivalent of a makefile. The 'devDependencies' section within 'package.json' guides the builder on what to exclude when creating the runtime component, ensuring only essential elements are packaged up.

Answer №2

It appears that your npm projects are primarily focused on frontend web development, such as projects related to vue/react/angular. If you haven't worked on a nodejs app before, it can be quite confusing.

For these types of frontend web projects, it seems there's little distinction between dependencies and devDependencies. This is because all dependencies are typically bundled into the final output js file. In fact, once you've installed all the necessary dependencies in the node_modules directory, you can even remove the items listed under dependencies in the package.json file and still successfully build the project.

With a released frontend project, you usually only have one bundled js file that gets deployed on a web server, requiring no further building or installation of dependencies. However, if you're working on a nodejs project, things are different. A released nodejs app consists of all the contents within the directory along with the package.json file. To run a nodejs app, you must first execute npm install --production to install all required dependencies before running the main js file of the package. While devDependencies aren't essential for simply running the app, they play a crucial role during the building and testing phases.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

Using Passport.js with client-side templating: A step-by-step guide

I've been using passport js for authentication, but I'm also implementing the angular $route service for client-side templating. This dual approach has left me uncertain about how to effectively utilize passport, especially since most of the exam ...

How can I view the number of downloads for a specific version of an N

I am aware of the existence of a public API for retrieving NPM download counts, as well as services such as npm-stat and npmtrends that make use of it. However, I am interested in accessing download data for specific package versions. Despite reviewing t ...

What is the process of incorporating a JavaScript node module into TypeScript?

Having trouble importing the xml2js module as I keep getting a 404 error stating that it's not found. import xml2js from 'xml2js'; Any suggestions on how to properly import JavaScript modules located in the node_modules directory when work ...

Issues with Fetch API and CORS in Web Browsers

Hello, I'm encountering an issue related to CORS and the Fetch API when using browsers. Currently, my setup involves running a NodeJS server built with Express on localhost:5000. This server responds to a GET request made to the URL /get_a, serving ...

Troubleshooting: Issues with PassportJS JWT Strategy Integration with Node.js and MySQL

My app's authentication feature is causing me trouble. Every time I try to run my server.js file, I encounter the error "TypeError: Cannot read property 'fromAuthHeaderAsBearerToken' of undefined at Object." which prevents me from moving for ...

Creating dynamic websites with Node.js, Express, and MongoDB

Hey there, Recently, I delved into working with Node.js along with Express and MongoDB. My initial setup included: /** * Dependencies. */ var express = require('express') , routes = require('./routes') , mongoose = require(&apo ...

Version discrepancy in module metadata

Yesterday everything was running smoothly with Angular 2 and Angular Material, but today I encountered an error when trying to run the program. Can someone please help? ERROR in Error: Metadata version mismatch for module E:/Demo/crud/ node_modules/ ...

What caused the sudden malfunction in the extended Express Request?

Currently, I am utilizing Node v12 along with Express v4.16.4 and Typescript version 3.8.3 within VSCode. This particular snippet of code has remained unchanged for almost 8 months and is utilized in all our routers. export interface ICustomRequest exten ...

Is it possible to replace the catch function in JavaScript with a custom function?

Below is the code snippet: function xyz() { try { var a = someexecutions(); handlesuccess(a) } catch (err) { handleerror(err) } } This type of function is repeated numerous times in my codebase and I am looking for a way to improve it. f ...

Combine a JSON object and a JSON array by matching the value of the JSON object to the key of the JSON array

I am looking to create a JSON array in node by combining two JSON objects and arrays. `var template = { "key1": "value1", "key3": "value3", "key4": "value3", "key6": "Dummy Value1" }; var data = [ { "value1": "1", "value2": "2", ...

The href attribute in a stylesheet link node is malfunctioning

When setting up my website, I experimented with two different methods. 1) The first method involved using node to run the server. 2) The second method simply used an index.html file on my local computer. Interestingly, I noticed a difference in how the s ...

employing async/await in the function of a backend API

I'm facing an issue with the following code snippet: service.js module.exports = { getUser }; async function getUser({ data }) { return new Promise((resolve, reject) => { const id = data["id"]; const doc = await db.colle ...

Exploring the world of WebSockets and Socket.io

Recently many online games, like , have started using WebSockets to create real-time MMORPGs. I'm curious about how to develop a node.js program that can manage connections from browsers using WebSockets. Here is an example of browser code: <!DOC ...

Having trouble accessing mariadb from my node.js application

Even though I am able to successfully log in using the same credentials from both Windows Command Line and MariaDB admin, for some reason I am unable to do so from my node.js app... const mariadb = require('mariadb'); const pool = mariadb.create ...

I'm having trouble getting React to start. Every time I try to run npm start, I encounter an error message

I encountered this error and I suspect it may be related to my package.json file. The default content of my package.json is as follows: { "name": "reactproject", "version": "0.1.0", "private": true, "dependencies": { "react": "^16. ...

Vue.js / Nginx / Node.js - Error 413: Payload Too Big

My frontend is built using Vue.js and is hosted on an nginx server in production. Here's a snippet of my nginx.conf configuration: server { listen 80; server_name localhost; root /usr/share ...

What is the best method for displaying private API-endpoint JSON data secured by Auth0-JWT within an Android application?

Having developed an Android application with a NodeJS backend, I have implemented a private API endpoint protected by Auth0. The NodeJS code for the private API looks like this: app.get('/api/private', jwtCheck, function(req, res) { res.json({ ...

CSRF token recognized as invalid in React application but verified as valid in Postman API

I have setup an Express server in which I am generating a CSRF token. The configuration of my server includes: const csrfProtection = csrf({ cookie: { httpOnly: true, }, }); server.use(express.json()); server.use(express.urlencoded({ extended: true ...

NPM is having trouble installing packages and seems to be stuck in the process

I seem to be experiencing an issue when trying to install modules with NPM. Every time I run the command, it gets stuck at this stage: npm install express npm http GET https://registry.npmjs.org/express This behavior occurs no matter what module I try to ...

What is the process for integrating MongoDB into Vue.js 2?

I've been trying to install mongodb through npm, but I keep encountering the error message "Cannot find module 'fs'." Here is a snippet of my code: <script> const MongoClient = require('mongodb').MongoClient; export defau ...