What should be used in Angular 2 Reactive Forms - controls or get()?

Lately, in templates, I've come across two different approaches:

myForm.controls.StartDate.value

and

myForm.get('StartDate').value

I initially thought that 'controls' was the recommended approach moving forward. However, when running ng build -prod, this causes a build error. Which method is considered best practice and won't cause issues during the build process?

Answer №1

After exploring the official Angular documentation on reactive forms, I discovered that they recommend using .get() on a FormGroup and .controls (in the template) on a FormArray. This distinction is important because a FormArray does not have named controls.

I also came across an article on handling forms in Angular 2 by Todd Motto, which mentions that there is no significant difference between using .get() and .controls, except that using .get() provides built-in error handling.

In my personal projects, I typically use .get() on FormGroup with success. It is challenging to determine which approach is superior nowadays. If .controls offers better IDE prompts, then it may be the preferred option - but without this feature, distinguishing between them can be difficult.

Furthermore, digging into the Angular source code repository, I found that .get() internally utilizes .find(), and .find() leverages .controls. Consequently, both methods should be safe to use, and either one should not cause issues in your production build.

Similar questions

If you have not found the answer to your question or you are interested in this topic, then look at other similar questions below or use the search

TimeoutException occurs in Browser when using Visual Studio with ASP.NET and Angular

After waiting for 60 seconds, an error message appeared in the browser when trying to debug. However, after refreshing the browser window and waiting for another 15 seconds, everything seemed to be working fine. An unexpected error occurred during the r ...

While developing an exam portal with Angular and Spring Boot, I encountered an issue when trying to incorporate a name field as [name]

Component.html <div class="bootstrap-wrapper" *ngIf="!isSubmit"> <div class="container-fluid"> <div class="row"> <div class="col-md-2"> <!- ...

Setting up the CHROME_BIN path in Jenkins environment variable for running Headless Chrome without Puppeteer can be achieved by following these

Currently, I am facing an issue in my Angular project where I can successfully run tests using Karma and Jasmin on my Windows local machine with headless chrome. However, Jenkins is giving me an error stating "No binary for ChromeHeadless browser on your p ...

The workspace does not have the 'development' configuration set for Angular 12 Universal

After creating a new Angular 11 project called "client", I updated the Angular version to 12 and installed Universal by running the command: ng add @nguniversal/express-engine. However, when attempting to run my Universal Angular project using the command ...

Trouble with Angular: Passing output between child components is not working

Just dipping my toes into Angular, I started learning it yesterday for a take-home job interview project. Please excuse any rookie mistakes in advance. For some hands-on practice, I decided to work on a basic project where the main component (app) has two ...

Having trouble with Angular 5's Post function?

Having some trouble with my Angular 5 application and API calls. For some reason, when I add headers to the request, the browser is not recognizing them properly and showing 'OPTION' instead of the actual headers. This is resulting in a 403 respo ...

Leveraging Sessions in Angular with Spring Boot

As I try to implement a login and session management system for my library portal, I have developed backend services using Spring Boot and frontend with Angular. While exploring an example of Spring Boot + Session Management on this link: , I made some adj ...

ControlValueAccessor failing to populate with data from external service

After realizing the previous question was slightly off track, I am focusing on creating a custom component that can be bound to a FormControl within a FormGroup. I have successfully made it work for user input using CVA, but facing issues when preloading ...

Angular: accessing public properties

I have a component called "user.service.ts" that I want to share. import { Injectable } from '@angular/core'; import { Http, Headers, RequestOptions, Response } from '@angular/http'; import { AppConfig } from '../app.config&apos ...

Ionic4: Troubleshooting the playback of audio files on a web-based application

Currently, my project involves using Ionic 4 in combination with Angular. I am facing a challenge where I need to play an audio file (mp3/wav) when an image is clicked. Despite working on this for a week, I have been unable to figure it out. Can anyone pr ...

Is there a way to transmit the wellness update of my Angular application to Akamai?

I currently have an Angular application and am utilizing the Akamai CDN. Can you advise me on the most effective method to relay the health status (200, 500, etc.) to Akamai? I want to ensure that in case it doesn't return a 200 code, Akamai is able t ...

The error message "Property 'chart' is not available in the - ChartJS - Angular 13" indicates that the specified property '

As a beginner in Angular, I am currently working on my first page using Angular and facing some challenges with implementing onClick functionality in ChartJS Bar graphs. The issue arises when attempting to access this.chart within the onClick event of Cha ...

A guide on implementing RxJS Observables to target a specific DIV element

Currently, I am working with Angular 2. At the moment, I have been using this method to select a specific DIV element: <div #aaa> </div> @ViewChild('aaa') private aaa: ElementRef; ngAfterViewInit() { let item = this.aaa.nativeEle ...

Assign a variable with the value returned by a function

Can you help me with this question I have about validating fields with a function using AbstractControl? errorVar: boolean = false function(c: AbstractControl): {[key: string]: string } | null { // validation if 'test' is true or not goes here ...

Implementing Angular2 with conditional loading

One of the requirements for my project is to redirect users to the login page before loading the Angular2 application, without actually loading it. The project is built using angular2-quicksart. After minifying the Angular2 js file: <script> va ...

Is it possible to achieve pagination by simply dragging the scroll bar to the top or bottom position?

Recently, I've been working on implementing a pagination function for a list of items. The pagination currently works well with scrolling events - it automatically moves to the next page when scrolling to the bottom, and to the previous page when scro ...

Adjust the dimensions of an Angular Material 2 dialog by updating the width or height

Is there a way to adjust the dimensions of an open Angular Material 2 dialog, either its width or height? I attempted to modify the size of the dialog by obtaining a reference to it and using the updateSize method within the dialog. Unfortunately, I belie ...

Adding TH into a TABLE in Angular 2 by verifying TD elements

I am seeking a way to automatically generate thead and th, using td in the template : <Datatable> <tr #lineSelected *ngFor="let subscription of results"> <td nameColumn="Nom">{{subscription.name}}</td> <td n ...

The URL "http://packagist.org/p/provider-3.json" was unable to be retrieved due to a bad request error (HTTP/1.1 400 Bad Request)

Encountering a 400 bad request issue when trying to connect over HTTP, despite the package only being installable via HTTP. Attempting to override in composer.json to force HTTPS as suggested by others for a workaround, but that solution doesn't seem ...

Angular's text interpolation fails to update when a value is changed by an eventListener

I am encountering an issue with two angular apps, one acting as the parent and the other as the child within an iframe. The HTML structure is quite simple: <div class="first"> <label>{{postedMessage}}</label> </div> &l ...