In my experience working on various projects, I have encountered the situation where I need to incorporate a Material UI component into a bootstrap component. Surprisingly, this integration has worked seamlessly and the user interface appears as expected. Despite this success, I have received advice against using this approach. Can anyone explain the reasoning behind this caution? Both frameworks utilize grids and are flexible, so what could be the potential issue?
I have a tendency to be quite detailed, so I will provide a concise answer upfront:
Summary:
The idea that it's frowned upon to use both options may simply reflect personal opinion. In reality, declaring it bad to use both lacks consideration of the specific project at hand. As @user3770494 pointed out, while concerns about build size are valid, the decision should align with the application's scope. For instance, in an intraoffice setting with high-speed local network access, caching could mitigate any performance issues. Personally, I wouldn't criticize someone for mixing them unless it's for a massive multi-platform application serving thousands of active users globally with real-time updates and dynamic content around the clock.
Ultimately, if it's not critical, my suggestion is to explore using both options and even experimenting on your own. Embracing multiple perspectives can lead to deeper understanding compared to sticking rigidly to a single solution, fostering personal growth.
You don't have to read beyond this point - it's optional :)
In my experience, I've utilized both approaches in production applications (in combination and independently) and built solutions from scratch... (I must admit, CSS isn't my favorite aspect of my work, but luckily I have a talented coworker who excels in it). Here are some reflections:
Heads up: I tend to get verbose!
Disclaimer:
Functionality often outweighs aesthetics for me, as design minutiae requested by clients are sometimes trivial. I'll try to keep subjective opinions about appearance out of this discussion as much as possible.
Currently, I'm evaluating options for a ReactJS / create-react-app setup to develop experimental projects for touch screen embedded systems. I plan to create several demos like CC scanners, barcode readers, GPS integrations, etc., just for fun using a Raspberry Pi 3B+ board.
Solution:
If you have the time, resources, and dedication, there's no harm in blending both methods. However, weigh the investment against the returns. DIY for user satisfaction, even when combining styles, or start from scratch entirely—it's recreating the wheel, but incorporating Bootstrap styles is an option.
One caveat: If you do opt for both, ensure careful balance and avoid excessive mixing to prevent potential conflicts during version upgrades.
I appreciate aspects of MaterialUI but have reservations about its default aesthetic choices. Functionally, I prefer it to Bootstrap, but I find MaterialUI's React programming techniques less favorable. Having to resort to "!important" repeatedly due to styling conflicts is a major downside for me, compared to conventions my team follows. It's not a matter of better or worse; certain aspects irk me despite being designed with good intentions.
Bootstrap offers diverse customization options and integrates well with ReactJS. The presence of reactstrap vs. react-bootstrap prompted my search for the optimal choice for the demo projects I'm working on.
Lately, I've mostly stuck to one framework for production endeavors, emphasizing functionality over design intricacies. Since UI elements take a backseat in these projects, employing a single approach streamlines my workflow. When necessary, I override styles manually if the default ones are unappealing. My choice isn't rooted in the belief that using both frameworks is taboo; rather, it aligns with simplifying my processes. If bandwidth is unlimited, utilizing both frameworks selectively can enhance quality without bloating the codebase.
(I once witnessed someone importing the entire jQuery library just to utilize $.ajax extensively—seemed excessive to me!)—When combining frameworks, optimize compilation to import only essential components. Following a Pythonic principle, refrain from using "import * from module" in JavaScript, letting webpack/gulp handle such optimizations automatically. Assuming ES6/7 style JS usage.
During a recent project, I found myself in a similar situation and decided to leverage the strengths of both frameworks for different purposes. Given the nature of the responsive web application, Bootstrap proved to be the ideal choice for handling the layout aspects while I preferred using Material UI for implementing various widgets.
Utilizing both options is feasible, but there are a few drawbacks to keep in mind:
In general, managing two different systems requires more effort and increases the likelihood of visual inconsistencies. However, incorporating simpler elements like a grid system with minimal theming variations may not pose as much of an issue.
If possible, it is recommended to select one system and commit to it for a smoother development process.
By utilizing both options, the size of your JavaScript production will be enlarged.
When deciding between Material Ui and Bootstrap, keep in mind that they offer components with similar basic styles such as buttons, so it's best to select just one.
You have the option to use Bootstrap grid solely for structural purposes or alternatively opt for flexbox.
import { useState } from "react"; function ParentComp(props){ console.log("parent component is rendering"); const [person, setPerson] = useState({ firstName: "First" }); setInterval(() => { setPerson({ firstName: "Second" }); }, 6000); r ...
I'm having trouble understanding why my deployment keeps crashing, as there are no significant error messages, only a bunch of warnings that it should still work (it has worked in the past with these same warnings). Here is the build log: Running bui ...
Is there a method to restrict access to the directory in NextJS? For instance, if I wish to prevent access to the directory /public/images? In that case, I would serve images through api routes. So, the image would be displayed in a component like this: & ...
I have been working on developing a component library consisting of multiple independent components. My objective is to enable users to easily import and use these components in their projects, similar to the following: import One from 'component-lib ...
I am currently working on a Next.js 14 app router and have a requirement to dynamically create an XML file when the API route is called and send it in response. Below is my code snippet: export async function GET(req: NextApiRequest, res: NextApiResponse) ...
While hosting my app on Heroku and running git push heroku main, I encountered the following error: panicked at 'the global thread pool has not been initialized.: threadpool builderror { kind: ioerror(error { kind: unsupported, message: "operatio ...
I'm looking to extract specific values from the enum below enum p { XDR = 1, PT1M = 2, PT1M_ = 2, PT5M = 3, PT5M_ = 3, PT15M = 4, PT15M_ = 4, PT1H = 5, PT1H_ = 5, P1D = 6, P1D_ = 6, P7D = 7, P1W = 7, ...
The functionality of this code is as expected, however, after the fifth GET request, it successfully executes the backend operation (storing data in the database) but does not log anything on the server and there are no frontend changes (ReactJS). const ex ...
After integrating the mui-color-input library into my create-react-app project, I encountered a problem with the component test despite the project building successfully. ● Test suite failed to run Jest encountered an unexpected token Jest fai ...
I am struggling to display the title of the selected object in this select element. Can anyone help me understand why my code is not showing the title? Here is the code snippet: const [selectedCategory, setSelectedCategory] = useState(""); const categor ...
Does React still require the use of zilverline's tap event plugin or has it been integrated directly into React's source code, eliminating the need for a tap delay? ...
As a newcomer to Next Js, I am currently attempting to incorporate a select all feature for checkboxes. I came across this resource that I have been following: https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/how-to-work-with-multiple-checkboxes-in-react/ My goal is to ...
Here is my current challenge: I am trying to implement a multiple select feature with checkboxes in React using Material UI. The desired outcome should resemble the image linked below: https://i.stack.imgur.com/TJl8L.png I have structured my data in an a ...
I'm facing an issue where I am trying to invoke a method from an onClick event within a class component: export default class WhiteListOptions extends Component { triggerPurchase = async (buyQty) => { await this.props.purchaseFunction( ...
Utilizing the Material-UI style to define the class. Now, I aim to adjust the height based on the browser's width. Is there a way to dynamically calculate this within makeStyles() or implement a workaround? This snippet below represents what I am t ...
I've been facing challenges while attempting to deploy my Next.js application with mongoDb on the Heroku platform. The build process is successful without any errors, but unfortunately, my app does not function correctly. Upon checking the Heroku logs ...
In my development setup, I have a react component that is embedded within two distinct applications each with their own webpack configurations. Within the component, I am utilizing a FontAwesome icon using the react-fontawesome library: <FontAwesom ...
I encountered an issue with the code snippet below in my Next.js app directory when utilizing useState: When trying to import a component that requires useState, I received this error message. It seems that the parent components are marked as Server Co ...
I am using a NativeSelect component. <NativeSelect input={<BootstrapInput/>} onChange={this.handleClick} > <option value="1">1</option> <NativeSelect> Is there a way to customize the color of the dropdown button in Nat ...
After successfully setting up my node.JS Express server to send JSON data from an API to the front-end, I deployed it on an AWS server. Now, I am focusing on developing the React front end of the project. However, when I try to make requests from localhost ...